Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Why Do Contractors Punish Customers?


It seemed like a simple request. Two years ago, we turned down an invitation to put our house on a Historical Tour since it was discovered our kitchen had Formica. My wife remedied that (as painfully told in SMI). She felt showing off your Formica was like shaving “Wrestlemania” in your back hair.

Anyway, this year we agreed. Of course, this meant “touching up” the house a little. Started with the painters. Who mentioned rotten wood to carpenters. Who mentioned damaged roof flashing to roofers. Who mentioned tree limb encroachment to arborists. I think you can see where this is going. Yet I was NOT prepared for this…

This touch-up has turned into a near renovation, since we’d never want complete strangers to think we didn’t polish the screws on the brass mailbox. Then they might assume you put your feet on the coffee table or something.

Can anyone out there relate to project creep? Click "Amen, brother!” here to post to Facebook.

As usual, some interesting endeavors in contractor land, as seen through the eyes of a normal consumer. Okay, normal was a stretch, but here goes –

ALL of these services are grouped as contractors, and all the “good and bad” mentioned relate to “your” contracting field regardless.

Painting – Gave clear “scope of work” on day one, with options for us to choose. This related to full house washing, partial painting of trim, partial ‘body’ of house with various options. The best thing he did was “set expectations.”  He said what he would and couldn’t do, plus what it would cost for each service, how long it would take, how many men would be there. If there was ever a rain or supply delay, he let us know before we were looking for him. He also had a yard sign out from day one, and has picked up over $10,000 in neighborhood work on that single, simple element. He did a great job too.

Marketing and Sales Grade = A-.

Carpentry – Though every wood house ever made is decaying as you read this, our 105 year-old wood is so tough I’ve broken drill bits in the baseboards. The new wood in the Lowe’s bin can be drilled with a Q-Tip. Our carpenter sought the correct thickness, seasoned wood, showed me he backprimed before installation and hid his seams perfectly. As impressive as this was, he had no card and made no attempt to network our neighborhood, so in our minds – and everyone around us – he has vanished.

Marketing and Sales Grade = C.

Roofer – The first question is … which one? I called a guy who has done 4 other roofs. Then my wife called. Then I left a final plea with his thoroughly inept Customer Repellant who said, and I quote – “He don’t always check his messages that much.” I asked, “Since he’s done a lot of other work for us, may I have his cell number?” She says, “He don’t like for me to do that. Maybe you can try back tomorrow.” I promise that happened. Are YOU getting the idea she could be costing him some business? And she did. The $2,400 minor repair went to Roofer #3, who was able to actually use a phone and show up. We basically chose him because he DID show up.

Marketing and Sales Grade = C. My guess is there’ll be no follow up after the first rain. If he does, I’ll move my grade to a 
B. If he stays in touch, an A.

Landscaper – Now this is interesting. My wife is a master gardener. She understands her yard, whereas I only understand not to walk directly on the flowers. When the “Mow, Blow and Go” service seemed a little reckless on adding pine straw, she called our specialist landscaper (does the fish pond, bedding plants, irrigation) who has recently gone into the weekly maintenance business. She switched our entire account to him because he “gets it” and is genuinely interested in the yard. The former company has been indifferent, treating her yard like a production line.

Marketing and Sales Grade for “old” landscaper = D.
Marketing and Sales Grade for “new” landscaper = B+.

Brick Mason – Our brick pathway was so crooked, only extremely drunk people could navigate it. Given that the average “old house tour” patron in our neighborhood is around 112 years old, I didn’t want to risk a “Life Alert moment” in the yard, or the lawsuit. So we were referred (by the landscaper) to an eager, delightful and skilled young man to redo a small portion of the pathway. Yet he perfectly pointed out to me other “problem” areas, priced the entire job instead and tripled his sales in about 15 minutes. His work is excellent. We’d definitely call him back and refer him. He’s too young to critique on marketing, but his work speaks for itself.

Sales Grade = A.

Marketing Grade = C-. He should at least get a sign, flyers and business cards. Minimal investment, maximum return.

You’ll notice that some of the contractors did excellent work, but sorry marketing, which is a crime. That’s because it “hides” your expertise from those who’d willingly pay to enjoy it. And refer it. And buy for years, or as long as you care. You’ll also notice – though I’m a recovering perfectionist – that their “prices” weren’t really part of whether they got the job.

They were all pre-screened as referrals, one from the next (though the first roofer was a sorry letdown. I guess the $8,600 job on Hudson, Ink’s ‘new’ building is too much trouble to call me back for). The third roofer was entirely unmotivated, unappreciative. I have seen more energy in a mud pie.

Any contact with customers is a chance to shine or stay in the shade. Some of these will get “Online Reviews” from me (provided they’ve claimed their listing and have a website to make that easy). If they’ve NOT claimed their listing, this is a crying shame, destined to shortcut their potential sales.

And if they want to continue to feed their business pipeline, they’ll stay in touch. Sadly, the landscaper is likely the only one to stay in regular contact, and that’s due to his “capturing” of a recurring revenue stream from us.

Though some of this sounds “negative” about the marketing and sales performance of contractors, actually it is an opportunity for others (you!) to stand out. How?
  • Acquire – Be diligent in seeking referrals from non-competitive businesses. Be diligent in keeping your name visible. In this case, the basic and primitive yard sign yanked in sales a $50,000 website did not.
  • Engage – Set expectations, show examples, references and testimonials. Keep communication strong. Assume nothing.
  • Keep – Regular contact can be as basic as a newsletter two times a year, but today’s consumer requires more regular contact and visibility from you. Is it too hard to send a short, helpful email once a month? (Our PowerSuite marketing program was founded on the premise of short, snappy, memorable contact in various media to stay ‘visible.’)
I hope this helps you in your business. I’m about to go home and enjoy my “refreshed” home. But if you expect to see me on the next Home Tour, I plan to decline.

Adams Hudson

Ever had project creep?


- See more at: http://salesandmarketinginsider.com/article-why-do-contractors-punish-customers.html#anchor

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

The Group of 20


I’ve probably gotten in too deep. Been accused of that before. This “group of 20” was something that 10 years ago, I’d have thought a thorough impossibility. Being immersed with the top 20 copywriters and marketing strategists in North America seemed outside my limited bounds. In my little world, these are the people that spin it. 

I get to be with them 4 times this year, for 10 hour days of what’s working, what’s not, who’s being influenced by what and, most importantly, why. They are not household names, but many make the household names so. 

This is my first year of allowance into the “Olympics” of marketing persuasion, a craft I dearly love, with a group of people I’ve mostly only read about.  (They’ve obviously lowered their membership requirements.) 

Yet it will be worth absolutely nothing without one thing. This ‘thing,’ so elusive, a hint of intention, a foggy outline of how things should be, will fail to manifest a molecule of improvement absent this single trait. I hope I have “it”...

It is action.

The thing which turned Steve Jobs from a weirdo dreamer to a visionary doer. Turned Edison from a time waster of failed experiments to the man who “illuminated the world.” Has turned a million ill-equipped guys from gland-ridden aggressive awkwardness into marrying the girl of their dreams.

At some point, you’ve got to ask her to dance.

Action trumps contemplation, renders intellectual debate to a deservedly neutered has-been. Most ponder. Few pursue. I hate – and I don’t even like writing that word – but I intensely dislike “acceptance of what shows up.”

Many are content to speak of the “might have beens,” the opportunity they almost took. Their conscience has a very fine scale, tilted by grams of unacceptable or always-defensible behavior. 

Then there’s the group that feels the limb they’re way out on might be a bridge. They get called “dreamer” a lot. Hushed conversations call them “risky.” Sometimes they’re just called “stupid” by those safely on the ground. Any misstep – and there are a few – gets labeled by the do-nothings as “I told you so.”

Yet fueled by the fail fast/succeed sooner mentality, the second group understands their mission may exceed the speed of light. They may recall Jesus as the ultimate challenger, the boldest confronter, whose 3 year ministry changed the world for two thousand years and counting. He stared down authority, challenged ridiculous rules, told “right” just how wrong they were. 

Absent the ability to heal the blind, turn water into wine or raise the dead, the rest of us have pretty small challenges to overcome. (But wow! What party tricks!) World-imposed limitations? Phooey. Convention based on old-thinking? Get out of here. So what if we fall? Long as you don’t kill yourself or those involved in your experiment, how bad can it be? 

Action. A small word that fits between those that set the bonfire and those content to be warmed by it, but are quick to point out where it’s lacking.

When this group asked me to join, I hesitated. I posed the “should I or shouldn’t I” to readers of this editorial. Cost was/is high (exceeding my first year’s salary in business, far more than I’ve paid for a few cars). I was half hoping to get talked out of it. I can always say, “I don’t have time.” 

Yet, you readers overwhelmingly slapped me with reality and basically said, “Do it, you idiot.” So I did. Hear me: 

I will fail you. I will fail myself. I will have wasted God’s most precious resource of time devoted to misplaced talent ... all unless one thing happens. And that is….

That one thing happens. 

So here’s to the dreamers. The action takers. The fools. The “no way you can do that” people who are where you are because you became deaf to critics, attentive to soul. Every entrepreneur reading these words knows who I mean and I mean you. The one with skinned knees, chapped hands and enough mistakes to fill two volumes … right next to the one called “Life Well-Lived.” 

Thank you for your support.  

UPDATE: 

I have just returned from this 2-day brain letting, where I was in the “Marketing Hot Seat” to gather the highest-action-to-results ratio for the 3 challenges I issued. I was allowed to record ONLY my part, as the group is understandably highly protective. 

Enough ideas and inputs popped forth to resolve 2 of the 3 rather handily. To my surprise, a small alliance was formed with a long-standing member who fully understood a particular dilemma I had. We have many commonalities of approach, business model and, fortunately, ethics. 

Two days later, a marketing group spawned from this one was formed online.  The sharing has been profuse and powerful. Action has already commenced. The result of seeking wise counsel in this mastermind environment has educated me beyond the admission fee. 

I vow you all to be the beneficiary.  Stay tuned.

Adams Hudson

Question: What’s something scary or risky you did that turned out pretty darn good? Would love to hear.
- See more at: http://salesandmarketinginsider.com/article-the-group-of-20.html#anchor

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Why Businesses Go Under


For years, restaurants and home service contractors have been in competition for a rather uninspiring crown: the greatest number of business closings. (Hovers north and south of 20% per year.) This is never pretty.

A creative chef opens a restaurant with very high hopes, though he placed too much emphasis on the curry-flavored ice cream, and soon enough, it’s gone. Dashed dreams and a funky smell lay just inside the “closed” sign.

An aspiring technician decides he wants to do contracting “his” way, because his boss has the IQ of a sand flea, but with even worse people skills. He soon realizes that it’s actually helpful to sell something at a profit. He should’ve realized this before his truck payments were 6 months behind.

There are 3 legs to any business. Lose one and you lose out. People fall in love with the first one, dabble at the second one and generally fail themselves and the business by overlooking the third one.

It is the basics, the fundamentals, the process of working these 3 legs that spell success or failure. You will NOT find a successful business that ignores them.

I’ll cover the first two quickly, since they’re: a) Not sexy and b) I know enough about them to know I needed to hire people who understood them.
  1. Technical Proficiency – This is about quality product, quality skills, production efficiency, the ability to do the “thing” you’re in business for. Great food at a restaurant, repair and installation from a contractor, brake and exhaust service from Midas.

    If you fall totally in love with this item, you are destined to remain a “technician.” That is: the chef, copywriter, mechanic and candle maker…  but business growth is not in your future, until you discover the next one.
  2. Business Operations – This is the structure, the organization and the management of people, product, prices and profit. If it can be counted, it’s here: staff number, inventory, equipment, dollars, hours. It’s all input and output, with presumably enough left over to call it a living.

    Obsession here leads to “system paralysis” where forms are created to keep up with forms, and there are meetings to discuss meetings. Though necessary, this part of the business has caused me to mentally create torture devices for the practitioners, none of which seem adequately painful.

    Yet there won’t be any operations to fund, profits to count or technicians to employ
    without this last one…
  3. Marketing and Sales – Unless you’re selling door-to-door, the order is important. Sales come from leads, leads come from marketing. Every dollar you now possess or will earn in the future started as a lead. Not enough leads? You’re going out of business, just a matter of how soon.

    Some goobers tell me, “Oh, I don’t do any marketing” and I want to see if I can detect light by looking in their ears. If you have a sign, a business card or visibly demonstrate good work, you’re marketing. Just depends on how much and how efficiently it’s fueled.

    I was at a National Conference recently, conducted a seminar on Lead Generation and hosted an exhibit. Had perhaps 120-150 exhibit visitors. In fairly short order, your mind begins to “group” conversations and questions to create order, patterns and, you guessed it -

    • One group focused on tools, technicalities, the craft as god, regulations, the latest equipment.
    • Another group focused on management, pay plans, the organization as god, structure, hierarchy.
    • A third group had the first two things in place, but focused on “completing” the triangle with sales and profit. Our discussion turned to marketing and lead generation. Yes, many came to see the “Lead Generation Machine” we’d built (you can catch a glimpse at the pieces here) but it was most interesting to see as we have all learned before that - -
You get what you focus on. It’s a choice. A personal example follows.

My wife and I have recently become empty nesters and our morning walks now generally lean toward attaining “balance” of business and happiness. We are still defining the terms, discovering the ways and means between the extremes. 
Such as - -

I want to build a meaningful business that doesn’t eat my organs in the process.

I want to play with her, children, automobiles to the degree any continue to benefit. (Bonus: cars don’t talk back. They just leak or misfire.)

Balance means I can touch all those “wants” while becoming a better, more appreciative soul, willing to share whatever is willingly taught me.

So, expect my focus to shift this year.

Expect us to build more automated “push-button” marketing programs that generate leads so YOU can focus on being a contractor. (Have just launched the first one.)  Expect the same out of customer retention programs for you.

And expect that while I “earn” a little more recreational pursuit this year, I won’t spend any time at restaurants with Curry Ice Cream on the menu

- See more at: http://salesandmarketinginsider.com/article-why-businesses-go-under.html#anchor

Monday, February 25, 2013

Some of What’s Old Will Hopefully Never Be New Again


My mother-in-law has officially never thrown anything away. Ever.

She is incredibly efficient, runs a tight ship and actually transmitted a “Coupon Clipping” gene to my wife that has occasionally made me go back home to retrieve a coupon worth slightly less than the gas it took to do so. In my family, we had the opposite gene, resulting in some highly efficient comments like, “Man, the air conditioner has put stalactites on the ceiling again. We better open a few windows!” But, I digress.

Anyway, at my mother-in-law’s house, you can find seriously old magazines, broken toys (anyone need half a G.I. Joe?), ashtrays that haven’t been used since Nixon and I think she’s saving burned out light bulbs just in case they come up with a cure. And she’s neat about it. I mean, this stuff isn’t like “Hoarders”; it’s, like, categorized.

But nothing compares to the treasure trove I just came across. This one photo pretty much says it all…


I came across a J. C. Penney’s catalog from 1977 containing hideosities I’ve either blanked out from having seen, or no one ever bought them, which might explain J. C. Penney’s current difficulties.

Every page of the catalog was a new fashion wonder of increasing horror. Please, fashion gods, do NOT ever let this come back in style. There were several of these “his ‘n’ her” outfits. To me, wearing this would’ve been an invitation to get Maced on sight. Any judge would vote in favor of the Macer.

Sales and Marketing Insider Adams Hudson
“Maybe it’s the shirt talking, but those wing-sized lapels are giving me impure thoughts.”

And I am so digging on the dude’s windswept hair. She is looking at him like, “I may have hairspray envy, but your El Rancho shirt is making me forget about it.”

With any luck, the models went into witness protection and have had their identities erased.

Yet many contractors are not so lucky.

Dated Marketing Alert

We recently offered no-cost MPIs (Marketing Performance Indicators) to properly analyze the marketing programs of over 100 real-live, legitimate contractors. No need to bore you with what we do, but it’s basically like a marketing “physical.” We found MANY contractors with media allocations that were like 1977.

And these are good folks with good companies, but wondered why their clientele’s average age has continually risen while little “new blood” is filling in behind them, or why leads have fallen faster than Disco’s demise. 
Here’s Why…
  1. Some are running Yellow Pages budgets approaching 30% of their total budget. (YP shoppers typically start at 55 years old.) Our current recommendations are under 14%, and dropping. Get smart with your allocations to extract maximum performance.
  2. Nearly 20% of our MPIs showed contractors with an “unclaimed” Local Listing. This means neither your mother nor Madam Conzella the Psychic can find you online. Get your listing claimed. We can do it here or you can choose any agency you like. The point is to get it done.
  3. Over 60% had no customer retention program. That is like seriously 1980s, and it means that their customers are very vulnerable to never getting a customer back from the 40% of contractors who had one! This type of marketing “shuts the door” on customer loss and can pile on new profit (by stemming attrition). Get a sample here.NOTE: Most of our clients have a Customer Retention program because we yell at them constantly, so the ‘real’ industry number is closer to 20%. Shocking.
  4. Sadder still, a full 50% (also known among math wizards as “half”) are dependent upon manufacturers for co-opped ads. Fine to get co-op money, but a “dependence” on it and the ads sends a VERY mixed branding signal to your market. Be careful. And finally –
  5. Though the individual ads weren’t quite as dated as the killer clothes in the photo, some were close. There were a LOT of “Institutional” looking ads, trying to appeal to everyone, with every product and service crammed into one ad. The current trend that works is message to market specificity. We’ve touted this for over 5 years in a row, with increasing results. “Match” your ads to your market and watch the leads increase.
So, dear contractors, take a look at your marketing and decide “who” it appeals to. If it’s not pulling in the leads, image or customer retention you want, it’s probably time for some adjustments.

Please, don’t let the 1977 J. C. Penney’s Catalog be your marketing model! Think of the shame it could bring your family… and your hairdresser.


- See more at: www.salesandmarketinginsider.com

Monday, February 11, 2013

Lights Turned Off, Viewers Tuned Out, Game Turned On

At the recent Super Bowl, someone apparently leaned against a rather huge OFF switch in the underbelly of the SuperDome. When they did, 108,000,000 television viewers saw the stadium lights go out. It is not known whether any of the 76,000 potentially over-served fans in the stadium actually noticed.

Advertisers don’t like it when millions of prospects grow bored and walk away from the television, especially when their $3.5M 30-second commercial hasn’t run yet. Darn the luck.

Marketing’s Inviolable Rule #1: Keep the audience. You cannot sell to an empty room, non-listeners, non-subscribers, or delete-happy index fingers.

This may “seem” obvious except that you’re paying for advertising seen by nobody. Exposed: A Minor Conspiracy, plus a surprisingly reliable money-making media...

Is this a marketing conspiracy?

Consider dozens of Yellow Page books stacked in an apartment hallway with no interested takers. Or on our lake house street, 4-5 newspapers in every recreational home’s driveway to drive the “delivery” numbers up. Or your banner ad that had a reported multi-thousand visitors… with not a single email or phone call to show for it.

How often are you spending money selling to an empty room? More than you think.

And today more than ever, viewers/readers/listeners have turned off… because they can. Tivo renders Television time-slotting useless. Pandora and subscription radio marginalizes radio air time. Spam and over-inundated inboxes makes your “free” email like raindrops pelting a roof.

The advertiser has lost control of the advertisee.

Your control, bought with your dollars, to touch your audience with your chosen message is what governs your marketing outcome.

See, in a “normal” circumstance, billion-dollar ad buyers would’ve had control of the Super Bowl audience. Heck, they’d be there for 3 hours or so, dying to see what Budweiser, Doritos and Dodge – the ad “winners” in order by the way – were going to come up with.

But no. Either the power bill on the Dome was overdue or a guy with a 32-ounce Hurricane (in the coveted $12 Souvenir Cup!) leans on the switch and ‘pfzzzzzt!’, no control.

A Brief but Meaningful “Lack of Control” Rant

The internet is everyone’s darling. Born of good vibes and lofty intention, it is the bastion of societal betterment (except that it is eating our brains, but that’s another matter).

You think your Local Listing is controllable? Guess again. I’m convinced that there is a room at Google just for insane math professors with severe short-term memory loss working toward an algorithmic apocalypse. And they don’t want converts.

You think your Social marketing is controllable? If Zuckerberg even thinks about creating more effective ad space, hordes of anti-selling but over-posting non-buyers begin designing a pyre-mounted stake just for him. Board meetings often discourage ticking off a billion people (though unless there is a rational business argument to keep them, I’m a bit stumped as to why not).

Oh, and those SEO analytics and Pay-Per-Click numbers you’re getting for your site? Too bad they aren’t currency, provable, real prospects, or even reachable for that matter. You spend a ton of time trying to “convert” numbers that are mythical at best.

Rant mostly ends here, but you get my point. Marketing to an empty room gets expensive.

Oh, to leave you with a media bright spot: The most enduring media stalwart – and one I continue to laud – is the lovably offline direct mail. Why? Three biggies right here:
  1. Targetability (as in specificity of chosen audience),
  2. Metering (choosing exactly how many), and
  3. Timing (mailed when you say, not when the media tells you) make Direct Mail one thing most other media are not:
Controllable.

Right, I know. The Pony Express barely serves your town any more. This means less competition in the mailbox rendering each piece therein more valuable.

In a sea of confusing or nearly conspiratorial numbers, it is time for you to regain control. This starts with the fullest and most attentive room you’ve got – your customer list. Make it your marketing’s mission to maintain an active customer base first.

You want to lose control of your customers? Here’s how: Forget about them for 6 months and see what happens. (I’ll go ahead and blow the surprise: 11% of them will leave you due to your indifference. Multiply that number by your average sale and gulp hard.)

You want to lose control of your “warm” social site prospects? Sell to them like an over-caffeinated circus barker. That’ll do it. Oh, just thought of another: Tell complete strangers to “like” you on Facebook, as if that’s enough.  You almost had them, but then lost control.

Marketing today has changed. Power has shifted. It’s more of a dance of parity than it used to be. Prospect and prospector a little tenuous, semi-suspect of each other. Make a customer mad today and he takes control back, revealing your misstep for all online. Delight a customer and give them reason to share it, and you win new customers at no expense.

Take control of your audience to help control your outcome. Leave them to chance, and there’s a chance they’ll leave you.

During the Super Bowl black out, announcers did their best to keep the viewing audience engaged, but coming up with new ways to say, “Man it’s really dark!” grew old, and the audience evaporated. San Francisco gave their fans a reason to rally with a highly commendable effort. Yet for them and the second half advertisers, it was too little too late.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

The President's Email Campaign

Recently, my left shoulder almost fell off. Okay, that was what I told my wife to get nonexistent sympathy. (Last time I had a cold: “Honey, my lungs are filled with lava; I require coddling.”)

Since I’ve had joint surgery on other limbs, my left shoulder felt ostracized, alone. So it developed a bone spur the size and sharpness of an eagle’s talon that dug into nerves, flesh and anything else to make you cringe on your way to sending a donation to help pay the orthopedist.

Perhaps charitable donation copywriting isn’t for me.

But it certainly was for the team that recently got 690 million dollars donated to Mr. Obama. Via email. All online. You read right.

Whether it’s political fundraising or contractor services, mass persuasion that drags nearly ¾ of a billion dollars with no direct benefit to the donor is a flat-out marvel. So how good would it work if you offered a very direct provable benefit? (I’m referring to you, dear contractor!)

A team of 20 writers and 4 strategists composed these emails, and allowed some students (including pain-riddled and groveling me) to review the techniques. And here they are…

This is not about political fund-raising. For this editorial expose, I could give a rip who got elected, or their platform. This is about the dissection of persuasion, and one you might employ, since the ONLY difference between a rotten marketing campaign and one that keeps you busy for weeks is your ability to persuade.

In fact, if you were NOT for Mr. Obama, then perhaps this is your rare opportunity to extract value from the re-election. Personally, I’d grab it.

Toby Fallsgraff, lead strategist for this avalanche of emailed millions, has a word he uses a lot: testing. So you can look at this very short list and draw two conclusions.
  1. You realize that its relative simplicity resulted from complex testing of 4.5 million coded responses, in layered double blind, A/B split testing that considered manifold data query, constantly re-setting the controls at each “win” or…
  2. You think it’s bunk and you want to do it your way.
Either way is fine by me; one of the choices can greatly impact you.
NOTE: Regular SMI readers and MegaMarketer members may recognize some steps from earlier research, also used in our Web Marketing PowerProgram. Yet to re-affirm their incredible effectiveness with added data, here you go:
  1. List Segmentation – Fallsgraff’s main 7-figure genius. He found that the more specific the emails were in recognizing donors, the more they donated. (My overly-repeated phrase “Specificity rules response.”)

    That is name, behavioral habit (“You gave $75 in 2008”) and familiarity-triggers. “At our age, you and I remember when…” etc. The days of “one ad fits all” copy is dead. Targeted, tonal copy matters, folks.

    The researchers found the Top donor groups as follows, and I’ve inserted the direct parallel equivalent (PE) in your business.

    • Previous – Those who’d given earlier in the campaign were asked again. PE: Most recent purchasers. Recent repair to old system credited to new system.
    • Quick – A subset of the above whose information was saved for the automatic payment. PE: “We have your information on file and can process your Agreement instantly.”
    • Non – Names on file but no donation. Copy was specially formed to move them forward. PE: A credible message, laced with testimonials, guarantees, “trust builders” and solid offer.
    • Lapsed – Those who’d donated in previous campaigns. PE: What we call “reactivation” letters and emails in our PowerPacks and PowerPrograms. These are mildly guilt-inducing, enticingly reactivating.

  2. Quick, Convenient – Short sentences, email length limited to 300 words, line length pared to < 10 words, paragraph depth < 6 lines, “donation options” shown 1 per line (reduced confusion, focused attention on single numbers) such as:
    $3
    $35
    $50
    $100
    $250

    Notice carefully chosen price points clustered where they felt most would give ($35-$50) and larger differentials at top and bottom.

  3. Conversion Magic – 300% increase in response here with one change. The ‘old’ way was to link to a brief form for demographic capture. (Nearly all fund-raisers function this way now in muted effort to segment.)

    Yet genius testing proved that those numbers automatically triggered payment, specifying with clarity, “Your donation will go through automatically.”  There is power in each word there, removing the mystical middleman, or processing costs, or other subtle impediments to unfiltered donation.

  4. Test the Message – The 20 top copywriters poured copy onto the strategists and programmers. Testing was fast and furious, with “winners” (we say “controls”) remaining king until toppled.

    As covered in Coaching calls and seminars, I often yell … I mean “coach”… about the importance of Subject lines. All the great copy, fancy linking software and sophisticated segmenting mean NOTHING unless…

    They open the email. Most writers treat subject lines like an afterthought, yet they’re the caviar of copy. (This very SMI tested 2 subject lines; I’ll publish the winner if you vote at the bottom.)

The #1 Subject Line.

Prior to the Web PowerProgram, I’d written perhaps 1,500 subject lines and pared down open rates to 3 categories:
  • Curiosity – Is this yours?
  • Situational – Was it something I said?
  • Impending event – This ends soon.
From these results, we ended up with 44 Subject lines (having just added 16 more for a collection of 60 “rip me open now” email lines) but the #1 Subject Line, out of over 200 written to nearly 3.4 million people for the most lucrative online fund-raiser ever conceived was synergistically linked to the emotions and sensibility within the target groups. It breaks new ground for Direct Response copywriters due to its first-person, near-defeated stance.

It read:

“I will be outspent.”

That email by itself, raised $2,600,000. (And yes, we’ve already written and are launching our test equivalents to this subject line, ready for the Version 3.0 PowerProgram to debut February 28 nationally. Want to be on the notification list? See below.)

Perhaps you can use these suggestions to help get some of your customers to donate to you. I suspect they’ll get more from you than promises and taxation.

Should you do really well, I’m still accepting donations for my shoulder. My orthopedist thanks you too!

Adams Hudson
  • Which is the more-opened subject line? (Results in next issue of SMI.)
    • TEST #1: Secret Email Strategy that Re-Elected a President
    • TEST #2: The President’s 690 Million Dollar Email Strategy
  • Click to be put on the Advance Notice list for the much-awaited Marketing PowerProgram 3.0. This program integrates offline and online marketing, and is an entirely new level of “done for you” marketing for contractors.          


Friday, January 11, 2013

Turn Brain Dust into a Brain Trust


Seemed a fair question. A few articles ago (11/28/12),  I asked you kind readers whether or not I should join Dan Kennedy’s Titanium Group. Let’s not mention that none of YOU has to pay the annual fee that is more than I spent for my daughter’s “nearly new” Honda Accord.

Some of you felt the fee was a bit of a rip-off. Of course, you answered fairly, based on what information I supplied. This was Unfair to you, since I do get extremely energized at the meetings, and felt more “one-on-one” would be helpful.

Yet most of you said – and I’m paraphrasing here – “Just shut up and join, then extract many nuggets of wisdom, and cast them my way on demand.” So yes, dear readers, I joined.

And a funny thing happened that I cannot explain, but will try: Though I have not yet attended a single meeting…

I’ve already extracted value beyond the entire year’s fee. And here it is…

Let me back up a second. Years ago when I began giving live seminars for various groups, an odd exchange took place. I was discussing arrangements with two different distributors, same time of year, same number of reachable dealers, same marketing topic, with the same fee quoted.

But their responses were quite different.

One said, “I have such a hard time filling the room, so that fee is pretty expensive.” Another said, “We’ll have no issue filling the room, so your fee is fine.” What was the difference?

The first one – surprisingly enough – didn’t charge his dealers anything. His assumption was “no barriers” meant a higher turnout. He saw dwindling, largely disinterested audiences of “about 20 or so” at his meetings, too often there for the coffee or to complain about the seating arrangements.

The second one – wisely enough – charged $59 a head, discounted to $40 each for additional attendees. He regularly put 50-70 eager contractors in a room who were more qualified, more interested and actively seeking a business advantage.

The lesson ended up being that dealers put a value on what they were there to learn; each formed a “you get what you pay for” mentality. The “free” 4-hour seminar reeked of low value, and perhaps a misuse of time. A slight fee elevated the value, the attention and the will to extract knowledge.

Lesson learned.

Since my newfound MasterMind group meeting was to be an “investment” of about $7,000 a meeting, a certain “value seeking missile” was ignited in my brain. (Or perhaps my “cheapness gene” went into self-protection, hard to say.)

Regardless, I adjusted our annual goals. This was eye-opening. I dropped one product entirely, but added focus to another. Later, an idea about subcontracting a troublesome part of Hudson, Ink to a better-qualified off-site expert emerged.

Then it became wise to extend “my” mastermind to include my managerial brain trust at Hudson, Ink, so I put 3 managers on a “Net Profit” bonus. This ignited their value-seeking missiles. Soon, ideas were formed out of this discussion on how we (Hudson, Ink) could build a better product launch for Spring in a more efficient, effective way. One example:

Instead of time and effort for Direct Mail that pointed recipients to a Landing Page, we decided to employ our Affiliate Partners to help us launch a video training series using email first. Based on the results of that, then a push using Direct Mail made more sense. (Direct mail, by the way, is still experiencing a rather large comeback, returning the best ROIs we’ve seen since 2007 across the board.)

So, before the first meeting, our focus began steering toward more meaningful goals, to be reached faster with greater overall benefit. Yet there’s a second reason I began doing this little exercise that has nothing to do with the money.

Competition.

In the room with other high achievers, I didn’t want to be the weakest link. I wanted to show up prepared and – if necessary – quantify reasons to belong, and share as I could. Maybe that’s my ego, but that’s what I was feeling.

I am now completely, thoroughly, positive that I’ll extract even more value, well in excess of the fee paid. There is indeed something magical and internally motivating about being in a MasterMind group. If belonging to, sharing with and being accountable to other success-minded people was NOT in your 2013 goals, I encourage you to add it. How?
  • Have a monthly “meeting” either online, in person, via phone/email where you provide an orderly exchange of ideas, goals, challenges with others.
  • Join an existing “best practices” group – could be one of the larger paid groups with “Live” events, a more casual ACCA Mix group or our MegaMarketers. (If you join in January, you get the whole first month complimentary, PLUS 2 training videos and downloads.)
  • Plan to attend at least 4 smaller, focused seminars and at least one large national seminar within your trade. 
  • Other? Tell me what you plan to do in 2013 to turn your brain dust into a brain trust: goals@hudsonink.com
My promise: The rewards of any of the above will far exceed your time and investment.

Here’s a no-cost video on the MasterMind concept explained more fully.